19 Comments
User's avatar
Amanda Cairns's avatar

I'm definitely in the minority but there is something about Der Kommissar that gets me bobbin' my head and I think the tune is a little catchier.

Expand full comment
Alejandro Saya's avatar

Hey Keith and Joe! It's funny how spanish always finds a way to sneak into any random category, in this case two very german songs! "Nena" is perfectly legit, is more colloquial than "niña", and it is used mostly en Spain, Argentina and probably Colombia. In Chile people would say "lola" instead of "nena". That being said, my vote goes for Nena and 99 Luftallons, mostly because I remember listening to the song at parties in my teens!

Expand full comment
Joe Wack's avatar

All right! Asked and answered. Thanks, Alejandro!

Expand full comment
The 80s-est's avatar

I KNEW you would come through for us! Thanks, buddy!

Expand full comment
John Booth's avatar

After listening, I thought I'd follow up with some thoughts on why America seemed fascinated by Germany in the 1980s. Musically, I'd theorize that some of it could be that the New Wave sound was so heavily built on the 1970s pioneering of Kraftwerk - a band I really wasn't familiar with until later in life, when I realized how they'd shaped so much of what I loved. On the broader landscape, the Berlin Wall turned 20 years old in 1981, and that East v. West conflict that shaped so much of the '80s was probably nowhere more physically symbolized than in the center of Germany. At the same time, symbols of American excess and wealth in the 1980s could be found in West German brands like Porsche, BMW, and (to a lesser extent) Audi. Maybe there was a kind of fascination in the two so very different faces of East and West Germany; maybe it was that Germany had both a terribly villainous past (Nazi bad guys in two of three Indiana Jones movies!) and a bleeding-edge eye on the future (again, auto engineering and musical experimentation). Anyway, danke für meine TED talk gekommen.

Expand full comment
The 80s-est's avatar

This is awesome, agree with all of this! And yeah, a lot of those brands you mentioned DO resonate 80s for me, especially BMW, which might be THE brand of the yuppie/ME decade! And also, I associate YOU with the whole thing because of your experience IN Germany and your ability to speak it/sing it!

--Keith

Expand full comment
John Booth's avatar

Nena remains a favorite, and enjoyed a huge career and recent-ish revival in Europe. If you've watched "Dark," - WHICH YOU SHOULD - you've heard another of her massive Euro hits, "Irgendwie, Irgendwo, Irgendwann," which featured in all three seasons and aptly translates to "Somehow, somwhere, sometime." ("Its various incarnations have charted over a 37-year period and in three different languages." - Wikipedia.) I also get you wanted this German pairing, but Falco is underrepresented by "Der Kommissar," since After the Fire's cover was much more popular here in the U.S., and "Rock Me Amadeus" didn't chart unti '86, so we'd better see it on Side B.

Expand full comment
The 80s-est's avatar

I loved "Dark"! I don't know that Nena song offhand, but I will go give it a listen, thanks!

I really wanted to get "Rock Me Amadeus" into this bracket instead of "Der Kommissar," but it was one of those borderline songs in late '85 that we assumed was an '86er due to chart performance. It was IN the bracket, and then got moved because of that. So there is a pretty fair chance you'll see it on Side B. Either way, I love "Rock Me Amadeus"!

--Keith

Expand full comment
Deni's avatar

I'm way behind on my commenting because I'm traveling and not able to listen as quickly (for some reason, when on a family vacation you family actually expect you to spend time with them and not sit around listening to podcasts).

I'm actually shocked Der Kommissar didn't chart in the U.S. Seems like everyone knows that song.

Expand full comment
The 80s-est's avatar

I hope you have a great trip, Deni! We will catch you when you get back! I guess it must have been the After the Fire version that we know better than the original? --Keith

Expand full comment
Leter Pames Jomax's avatar

Haha, no worries dude ... Aki e'tamo

Expand full comment
Leter Pames Jomax's avatar

My terrible attempt at the local accent down here 😆

Expand full comment
The 80s-est's avatar

Does this translate to "Love you anyway, bro, despite you saying stupid shit"? --Keith

Expand full comment
Leter Pames Jomax's avatar

😂 maybe if it was about me

Expand full comment
Rush's avatar

“Ja” is pronounced YAH auf Deutsch 😘

Expand full comment
The 80s-est's avatar

So are they saying "Ja" in this song, then?

Expand full comment
Rush's avatar

That I don’t know! It sounds like Zsa Zsa (as in Gabor). If they were saying yes, it would sound like YAH not JAH (hard J). Just a ‘toid from down south here.

Expand full comment
Leter Pames Jomax's avatar

Yeah, people say 'nena' here (in Sevilla) all the time as an affectionate way to refer to a girl.

Expand full comment
The 80s-est's avatar

Oh, man, I thought you had moved back to the UK for some reason, sorry, I was mistaken! --K

Expand full comment